Some of them were there to sing all the praises they had about family members from previous generations that had served in those same places. There was a lot of pride coming from those talks, and it made me feel full to bursting with the joy that these women at least communicated to their children and grandchildren that they felt their jobs allowed them plenty of dignity because of what strong women they were to begin with and what steadfast work they always knew they did. However, I had to remind myself that this was them making the best of their terrible situation at times.
The one that really hit me, however, was the admission from a white student no older than me that there was a certain level of shame he felt in having grown up with a “Mammy”, as one woman dubbed them. He had little more to say than the fact that he felt particularly stricken by the idea that he and his family contributed to the same kind of struggles and unfairness.
It made me sit back and wonder to myself how I would feel about having been raised by a black woman and then being confronted with a movie like this. Obviously, plenty of maids—or “domestic technicians, as one woman insistently called them—have different experiences ranging from unusually good to horribly bad. And unless my parents had raised their voice against a maid and given me some sense of panic, I would probably never have questioned whether or not the maid was being treated fairly. I certainly wouldn’t know how about maybe how far she had to travel and at what inconvenience. I wouldn’t know what sort of wages she would have been making. And I think I would feel a certain level of shame for having assumed that she loved her job as much as I probably would have loved her there. Of course, the movie did touch on the complex tangle of feelings that the maids might have had if they felt emotionally connected to a child, so it wasn’t as if they all hated what they did. But watching a guy in his early twenties admit that he had to rethink his childhood a bit hits you.
It was a gently eye-opening experience that I'm glad I had the chance to sit in on.